diff --git a/ts/modules/accounts.ts b/ts/modules/accounts.ts
index 8ae2b6b..fd642d7 100644
--- a/ts/modules/accounts.ts
+++ b/ts/modules/accounts.ts
@@ -925,7 +925,7 @@ export class accountsList extends PaginatedList {
             getPageEndpoint: "/users",
             itemsPerPage: 40,
             maxItemsLoadedForSearch: 200,
-            newElementsFromPage: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
+            appendNewItems: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
                 for (let u of ((resp as UsersDTO).users || [])) {
                     if (u.id in this.users) {
                         this.users[u.id].update(u);
@@ -940,7 +940,7 @@ export class accountsList extends PaginatedList {
                     this._search.ascending
                 );
             },
-            updateExistingElementsFromPage: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
+            replaceWithNewItems: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
                 let accountsOnDOM: { [id: string]: boolean } = {};
 
                 for (let id of Object.keys(this.users)) { accountsOnDOM[id] = true; }
diff --git a/ts/modules/activity.ts b/ts/modules/activity.ts
index a168cee..26d8a93 100644
--- a/ts/modules/activity.ts
+++ b/ts/modules/activity.ts
@@ -503,7 +503,7 @@ export class activityList extends PaginatedList {
             getPageEndpoint: "/activity",
             itemsPerPage: 20,
             maxItemsLoadedForSearch: 200,
-            newElementsFromPage: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
+            appendNewItems: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
                 let ordering: string[] = this._search.ordering;
                 for (let act of ((resp as ActivitiesDTO).activities || [])) {
                     this.activities[act.id] = new Activity(act);
@@ -511,12 +511,16 @@ export class activityList extends PaginatedList {
                 }
                 this._search.setOrdering(ordering, this._c.defaultSortField, this.ascending);
             },
-            updateExistingElementsFromPage: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
+            replaceWithNewItems: (resp: paginatedDTO) => {
                 // FIXME: Implement updates to existing elements, rather than just wiping each time.
+                
+                // Remove existing items
                 for (let id of Object.keys(this.activities)) {
                     delete this.activities[id];
                 }
-                this._c.newElementsFromPage(resp);
+                // And wipe their ordering
+                this._search.setOrdering([], this._c.defaultSortField, this.ascending);
+                this._c.appendNewItems(resp);
             },
             defaultSortField: ACTIVITY_DEFAULT_SORT_FIELD,
             defaultSortAscending: ACTIVITY_DEFAULT_SORT_ASCENDING,
diff --git a/ts/modules/list.ts b/ts/modules/list.ts
index b21a408..2335a2c 100644
--- a/ts/modules/list.ts
+++ b/ts/modules/list.ts
@@ -85,8 +85,8 @@ export interface PaginatedListConfig {
     getPageEndpoint: string;
     itemsPerPage: number;
     maxItemsLoadedForSearch: number;
-    newElementsFromPage: (resp: paginatedDTO) => void;
-    updateExistingElementsFromPage: (resp: paginatedDTO) => void;
+    appendNewItems: (resp: paginatedDTO) => void;
+    replaceWithNewItems: (resp: paginatedDTO) => void;
     defaultSortField: string;
     defaultSortAscending: boolean;
     pageLoadCallback?: (req: XMLHttpRequest) => void;
@@ -238,7 +238,7 @@ export abstract class PaginatedList {
         let timer = this._search.timeSearches ? performance.now() : null;
         if (visible) this._visible = elements;
         else this._visible = this._search.ordering.filter(v => !elements.includes(v));
-        console.log(elements.length, visible, this._visible.length);
+        // console.log(elements.length, visible, this._visible.length);
         this._counter.shown = this._visible.length;
         if (this._visible.length == 0) {
             this._container.textContent = ``;
@@ -341,7 +341,7 @@ export abstract class PaginatedList {
             
             this.lastPage = resp.last_page;
             
-            this._c.updateExistingElementsFromPage(resp);
+            this._c.replaceWithNewItems(resp);
             
             this._counter.loaded = this._search.ordering.length;
             
@@ -397,7 +397,7 @@ export abstract class PaginatedList {
 
             this.lastPage = resp.last_page;
 
-            this._c.newElementsFromPage(resp);
+            this._c.appendNewItems(resp);
            
             this._counter.loaded = this._search.ordering.length;